Too many of Ireland’s best are no longer good enough


Eighteen years have passed since Liam Brady became head of youth development at Arsenal. As one of the club’s greatest ever players, the man who once won the Scudetto for Juventus with a penalty in the final game of the season arrived back at Highbury with a specific task. He was charged with rebuilding the academy and under-age set up. Of course, as an Irishman, Brady gave himself a wider remit than just that. The Dubliner wanted to bring more Irish on board because it just seemed wrong even in the mid-90s that Niall Quinn had been the last of his compatriots to break through from the youths to the first team.


After close on two decades in office, Brady retires this month with not a single Irish lad at the club. Worse still, nobody came through in the interim to replicate the journey made by Quinn.  When asked about the lack of Irish over the years – Graham Barrett, Keith Fahey and Anthony Stokes all threatened to make it to the first team but had to move on to do so – Brady was typically candid. He felt that the coaching in Ireland was so far behind other countries that an outfit like Arsenal had to look elsewhere. Many people took that criticism badly but Brendan Rodgers said something very similar last week.


“It’s a lot more difficult now,” said Rodgers when asked about the lack of Irish at the top clubs. “A lot of them (Irish lads) start the apprenticeship at 16 but even then it’s too late as a lot of boys across the water are beginning at the age of eight and by the time they’re 16 they’ve been trained technically, tactically, physically and mentally and then they’re ready to step into full-time football.”


So the most skillful Irish midfielder of the past half century and the Irishman most likely to manage a club to a Premier League title anytime soon have basically told us the same thing. The Irish boys are not getting the coaching required to allow them to measure up against the best teenage talents from other countries. This is not news to anybody who has been paying attention. The problem is not everybody is paying attention. Too many people in positions of power seem to be ignoring the fact there is something seriously wrong with the way Irish players are being developed.


Witness the recent over-reaction to Seamus Coleman being voted onto the PFA Premier League team of the season. This was a great accolade for the Everton man and an acknowledgment of his growth as an attacking force over the course of the campaign. Even if his defending still needs some serious work (something that could be said about most full-backs these days), it’s obvious that his fellow pros have seen up close that he’s become a serious player at that level. But, the worrying thing here is that too few people were willing to point out something truly troubling about Coleman’s award.


The Donegal man was the first Irish footballer in five years to make the Premier League’s best XI and nobody thought this was, you know, seriously worrying. One every five years? Is that what we are reduced to? Is that the kind of token recognition that will make the decision-makers in the FAI convinced everything is going fine? Just as a comparison to that depressing statistic, three different Belgians have figured on the PFA Premier League team of the season in the same time frame. A small illustration of how we are falling behind nations we once considered our equals.


In a different country, this might be cause for alarm. The head honchos in charge of the sport might convene a conference at which those with a vested interest in the future of the game might come together. Over the course of a few days, they could talk about the problems on the ground, the issues confronting the grass-roots and the obstacles impeding the progress of our brightest young players.  They might even come up with a few solutions to the most glaring problems. They could even invite experts from abroad to offer advice on what changes to implement.


In Ireland, under the stewardship of the FAI, there is no crisis. The World Cup will go on without us next month and nobody will care that we aren’t there. Unlike Wales or Sweden, the cognoscenti won’t be lamenting Ireland’s failure to qualify for Brazil because it’s denying a special talent like Gareth Bale or Zlatan Ibrahimovic from playing on the biggest stage. Why not? Because we have no special talent right now. And, from what all those working at the coal face are saying, there isn’t any coming through. But, never mind, there’s no crisis.


Roy Keane and Martin O’Neill have been attending matches all over England and Scotland but the nearest we get to a hint of them adding new quality to their squad is talk of persuading players born and reared in other countries to consider switching allegiance. That’s a legitimate tactic in a world where nationality has become an all too fluid concept in so many professional sports. But, even if we persuade one or two up and comers with Irish ancestors to wear green, we shouldn’t be blinded to how bad things are in terms of the type of players we are producing these days.


Unless something crazy happens with Coleman’s future at Goodison Park, Anthony Stokes will be the only Irishman with a serious chance – Celtic’s successful navigation of the qualifying rounds permitting, of starting a game in the group stages of the Champions’ League next season. Like it or not, the Champions’ League is now the benchmark in the world game. It is where the best play and the best want to play. That the Irish representation has diminished from the glory days when two Corkmen could start a final for Manchester United to Stokes ploughing a lone furrow is another reflection of the falling standards. But don’t worry, according to the FAI, there’s no crisis.


14 thoughts on “Too many of Ireland’s best are no longer good enough

  1. Hello, I enjoyed reading your article and ofc I am a lover of football. Sometimes I wish one of the premier league teams recruited an all English team with the best talents we had and helped them progress. This would also help younger players and our England team. Atm we are hiring too many foreign players and it is hurting us. I would rather lose in a time of learning and improving than destroying our youth and progression.

  2. Great to see someone actually addressing this issue. Great read but it sure does tells a said story for Irish football. I’m Irish-South African and it’s the same story here in South Africa – worse, in fact. What are we to do? Support England? Now that’s a depressing thought.

  3. Fantastic piece, when you look at the money that has been plowed into Irish football over the years it is simply not acceptable that we are now barely even “also rans” on the world stage. When the GAA and the IRFU invest in their grassroots you see the benefits with fantastic facilities all over the country but when it comes to the FAI all they can point to is an often half empty Aviva stadium.

  4. Excellent post! The old romantic in me still remembers the success of the Greek national side in winning the Euros a decade ago. There weren’t many superstars on that team but it’s amazing what a well organised, technically drilled sum of individuals can achieve for the greater good of the team. Whether we will ever come close to matching those dizzy heights anytime soon under the new Dream team…we can only hope!

  5. Hi Dave. Nice article. It seems counter intuitive to ‘like’ a piece that is such an indictment of FAI’s short term vision. It wouldn’t be too much of a stretch to implicate a lot of other sports in Ireland too.

    The FAI really is a disturbing outfit but when you have someone like John Delaney calling the shots you know we’re in deep s**t. I don’t doubt Sepp Blatter is his personal hero and inspiration – men of integrity and vision, passionate about reinvigorating their chosen sport in a transparent, progressive way. And if anyone believes that they’ll believe Ireland are a credible force in world football and a ‘coming nation’.

    It really is depressing stuff. The game has evolved immeasurably and we’re still in the cave, kicking moss-covered rocks back and forth. I wonder what Keane makes of it all, now that he’s back in the fold?

    Anyway, it’s like looking in a septic tank and wondering how little crap you can dispose of before the smell goes away. Guess what – it goes all the way to the bottom!

  6. And buried in the middle of a great post is surely the subject of another post – what the hell is the story with full-backs these days?!? Jose builds his teams on them. No other Premiership manager (except maybe Pulis) seems to know what they even look like (and Fergie is not exempt, he had the magnificent Dennis Irwin but it was he who signed and played Rafael).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s